The Paradigm Shift in Indonesian Contract Law: A Case Study of Oral Employment Agreements Amid the Demand for Written Legal Certainty

Dian Wijaya (1), Rahmad Bakhri (2)
(1) Universitas Islam Negeri Bukittinggi, Indonesia,
(2) Universitas Andalas, Indonesia

Abstract

Oral agreements remain deeply embedded in Indonesian economic life, and their consequences are most acute in employment relationships, where a large informal workforce is routinely engaged through spoken understandings. Indonesian contract law, inherited from the Burgerlijk Wetboek, adheres to the principle of consensualism, and the Manpower Law expressly allows employment agreements to be made orally or in writing. At the same time, written form is required for fixed-term employment agreements, an employer who hires orally on an indefinite-term basis must issue a letter of appointment, and civil procedure continues to privilege written evidence. This study uses oral employment agreements as a case study of the position of oral contracts amid the demand for written legal certainty. It analyses the normative validity of oral employment agreements, their treatment in the evidentiary system and in selected decisions of the Supreme Court and the Industrial Relations Courts, and the direction of the paradigm shift towards written and electronic certainty. This study employs normative legal research using statutory, conceptual, and case approaches, drawing on primary legal materials, judicial decisions reported in the scholarly literature, and secondary legal materials. The findings show that oral employment agreements are valid and give rise to the full range of worker entitlements, but that their enforceability depends on proof of the elements of work, wages, and orders. The case study also reveals a distinctive feature of employment law: the legal risk of orality is shifted onto the employer, who controls documentation, most visibly through the treatment of unwritten fixed-term agreements as indefinite-term agreements. The paradigm shift identified is therefore evidentiary and protective rather than substantive. This study concludes that a balanced model is required, one that preserves consensualism while strengthening employer documentation duties, judicial guidelines on proving employment relationships, and simple documentation practices for informal workers.

Full text article

Generated from XML file

References

A. Setiawan and others, ‘Keabsahan Perjanjian Kerja Waktu Tertentu Yang Dibuat Secara Lisan Menurut Undang-Undang Ketenagakerjaan’, Wijayakusuma Law Review, 5.1 (2023) https://doi.org/10.51921/wlr.v5i1.228

A. W. Firmansyah, R. Alauddin, and F. Malik, ‘Perkembangan Kedudukan Dan Kekuatan Bukti Elektronik Dalam Sistem Pembuktian Perdata’, Amanna Gappa, 30.1 (2022), 60–74

Aan Handriani and Edy Mulyanto, ‘Kepastian Hukum Terkait Pentingnya Melakukan Perjanjian Tertulis Dalam Bertransaksi’, Pamulang Law Review, 4.1 (2021), 1–10 https://doi.org/10.32493/palrev.v4i1.12787

Agus Yudha Hernoko, Hukum Perjanjian: Asas Proporsionalitas Dalam Kontrak Komersial (Jakarta: Kencana Prenada Media Group, 2010)

Ahmadi Miru, Hukum Kontrak Dan Perancangan Kontrak (Jakarta: RajaGrafindo Persada, 2008)

Akbar Wahyu Purnawan and Miko Aditiya Suharto, ‘Pembuktian Perjanjian Lisan Dalam Sengketa Hutang Piutang: Studi Putusan PN Balikpapan No. 146/Pdt.G/2021’, Jurnal Ilmiah Advokasi, 13.4 (2025) https://doi.org/10.36987/jiad.v13i4.7574

Antara, ‘MK: Jangka Waktu PKWT Paling Lama Lima Tahun’, 31 October 2024, https://babel.antaranews.com/berita/444701/mk-jangka-waktu-pkwt-paling-lama-lima-tahun

Arwin Ardianto Sunardi, Fendi Setyawan, and Firman Floranta Adorana, ‘Pengembangan Hukum Perjanjian di Indonesia: Dalam Kekuatan Hukum Perjanjian Tidak Tertulis atau Perjanjian Lisan’, Jurnal ISO: Jurnal Ilmu Sosial, Politik dan Humaniora, 6.1 (2026), 13 https://doi.org/10.53697/iso.v6i1.3583

Berliana Adinda Ayu Puspita and Marwiyah, ‘Perjanjian Tidak Tertulis Ditinjau Dalam Sudut Pandang Hukum Perdata’, MAGISTRA Law Review, 5.01 (2024), 57–70 https://doi.org/10.56444/malrev.v5i01.5325

Billy Dicko Stepanus Harefa and Tuhana, ‘Kekuatan Hukum Perjanjian Lisan Apabila Terjadi Wanprestasi (Studi Putusan Pengadilan Negeri Yogyakarta Nomor 44/Pdt.G/2015/PN.Yyk)’, Privat Law, 4.2 (2016), 113–22

Bisnis.com, ‘Jumlah Pekerja Berusaha Sendiri Melonjak 1,38 Juta per Mei 2026’, 5 August 2026, https://ekonomi.bisnis.com/read/20260805/12/1993845/jumlah-pekerja-berusaha-sendiri-melonjak-138-juta-per-mei-2026

Burgerlijk Wetboek voor Indonesië (Indonesian Civil Code), Staatsblad 1847 No. 23

Chindy Maydiana Marsuseno, Anggrita Esthi S, and Karim, ‘Analisa Kekuatan Hukum Perjanjian Secara Lisan Saat Terjadi Wanprestasi (Studi Kasus Putusan Pengadilan Nomor 16/Pdt.G/2011/PN.Bjn)’, Jurnal Judiciary, 2.3 (2020)

Commission IX of the House of Representatives, Rancangan Undang-Undang tentang Pelindungan Ketenagakerjaan (committee text, file dated 28 September 2026), https://berkas2.dpr.go.id/akd/dokumen/komisi9-RJ-20260928-034348-6645.pdf

Constitutional Court of the Republic of Indonesia, Decision Number 168/PUU-XXI/2023 (31 October 2024)

Constitutional Court of the Republic of Indonesia, ‘Pemerintah: Aturan Perjanjian Kerja dan Alih Daya dalam UU Cipta Kerja Lindungi Buruh’, https://www.mkri.id/berita/-20123

David Herianto Sinaga and I Wayan Wiryawan, ‘Keabsahan Kontrak Elektronik (E-Contract) Dalam Perjanjian Bisnis’, Kertha Semaya: Journal Ilmu Hukum, 8.9 (2020), 1385–95 https://doi.org/10.24843/ks.2020.v08.i09.p09

Deanna Fitri Roshandi, ‘Analisis Keabsahan Perjanjian Lisan Menurut Hukum Perdata di Indonesia’, Konsensus: Jurnal Ilmu Pertahanan, Hukum dan Ilmu Komunikasi, 2.4 (2025), 114–21 https://doi.org/10.62383/konsensus.v2i4.1195

Disriani Latifah Soroinda and Anandri Annisa Rininta Soroinda Nasution, ‘Kekuatan Pembuktian Alat Bukti Elektronik Dalam Hukum Acara Perdata’, Jurnal Hukum & Pembangunan, 52.2 (2022) https://doi.org/10.21143/jhp.vol52.no2.3344

Efa Laela Fakhriah, ‘Penemuan Hukum Oleh Hakim Melalui Pembuktian Dengan Menggunakan Bukti Elektronik Dalam Mengadili Dan Memutus Sengketa Perdata’, Jurnal Bina Mulia Hukum, 5.1 (2020) https://doi.org/10.23920/jbmh.v5i1.50

Elanda Harviyata Trivirananto, ‘Analisis Putusan Mahkamah Agung Nomor 016 K/Pdt.Sus/2011 tentang Hak Pekerja dengan Perjanjian Kerja yang Dibuat Secara Lisan’, NOVUM: Jurnal Hukum, 1.3 (2014), 186–90 https://ejournal.unesa.ac.id/index.php/novum/article/view/8988

Elisabeth Nurhaini Butarbutar, ‘Arti Pentingnya Pembuktian Dalam Proses Penemuan Hukum di Peradilan Perdata’, Mimbar Hukum, 22.2 (2010)

Fajar Sahat Ridoli Sitompul and I Gusti Ayu Agung Ariani, ‘Kekuatan Mengikat Perjanjian Yang Dibuat Secara Lisan’, Kertha Semaya: Journal Ilmu Hukum, 2.5 (2014)

Faradilla Pratiwi, Ratna Artha Windari, and Si Ngurah Ardhya, ‘Kekuatan Pembuktian Dalam Perjanjian Utang Piutang Yang Dibuat Secara Lisan (Studi Kasus Putusan Nomor 139/Pdt.G/2022/PN Sgr)’, Jurnal Locus Delicti, 6.1 (2025), 13–26 https://doi.org/10.23887/jld.v6i1.5952

Government Regulation of the Republic of Indonesia Number 24 of 1997 on Land Registration

Herzien Inlandsch Reglement (HIR), Staatsblad 1941 No. 44

Hilman Hadikusuma, Hukum Perjanjian Adat, 4th edn (Bandung: Citra Aditya Bakti, 1990)

I Wayan Agus Vijayantera, ‘Kajian Hukum Perdata Terhadap Penggunaan Perjanjian Tidak Tertulis Dalam Kegiatan Bisnis’, Jurnal Komunikasi Hukum (JKH), 6.1 (2020), 115–25 https://doi.org/10.23887/jkh.v6i1.23445

I. Y. Hanifah, Khoirotunnisa, and L. D. Nugroho, ‘Analisis Yuridis Kekuatan Pembuktian Perjanjian Lisan Dalam Penyelesaian Sengketa Wanprestasi Berdasarkan Putusan Pengadilan No: 44/Pdt.G/2025/PN.YYK’, Justness: Jurnal Hukum Politik dan Agama, 5.2 (2025) https://doi.org/10.61974/justness.v5i2.91

Ida Ayu Ketut Cintiya Dewi and Dewa Ayu Dian Sawitri, ‘Keabsahan Perjanjian Lisan Dalam Persfektif Hukum Positif di Indonesia (Studi Kasus Perkara Perdata Nomor 44/Pdt.G/2015/PN.Yyk)’, Kertha Wicara: Journal Ilmu Hukum, 12.10 (2024), 508–16

Immanuel Wibowo Siagian and I Gede Putra Ariana, ‘Perjanjian Lisan Sah Sebagai Bukti Dalam Peradilan Perdata’, Kertha Negara: Journal Ilmu Hukum, 11.9 (2023), 1045–53

Jessika Morisca Katu, Ni Komang Arini Styawati, and I Made Aditya Mantara Putra, ‘Tinjauan Yuridis Terhadap Akibat Hukum Perjanjian Kerja Secara Lisan Antara Pekerja Dan Perusahaan’, Jurnal Konstruksi Hukum, 5.1 (2024), 66–71 https://doi.org/10.22225/jkh.5.1.8598.66-71

Juliati Br Ginting, ‘Kekuatan Mengikat Perjanjian Secara Lisan’, The Juris, 6.2 (2022), 429–36 https://doi.org/10.56301/juris.v6i2.612

Kompas.id, ‘Dokumen UU Pelindungan Ketenagakerjaan 2026 Akhirnya Terbit’, https://www.kompas.id/artikel/dokumen-uu-pelindungan-ketenagakerjaan-2026-akhirnya-terbit

Kontan, report on BPS labour force data for February 2026, https://nasional.kontan.co.id/news/pekerja-formal-baru-40-pemerintah-dorong-industri-dan-serapan-kerja

Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 11 of 2008 on Electronic Information and Transactions, as last amended by Law Number 1 of 2024

Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 13 of 2003 on Manpower

Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 2 of 2004 on Industrial Relations Dispute Settlement

Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 27 of 2026 on Employment Protection

Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 5 of 1960 on Basic Agrarian Principles

Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 6 of 2023 on the Stipulation of Government Regulation in Lieu of Law Number 2 of 2022 on Job Creation into Law

Muhamad Abdul Jamil Rizki and Ariawan Gunadi, ‘Kedudukan Status Perjanjian Kerja Waktu Tertentu bagi Pekerja yang Tidak Memiliki Kontrak Kerja Tertulis (Studi Putusan Mahkamah Agung Nomor 3K/PDT.SUS-PHI/2025)’, Riwayat, 8.4 (2025) https://doi.org/10.24815/jr.v8i4.51170

Ernawati, N. W., Irawan, A., & Basri. (2025). Penerapan nilai keadilan terhadap anak dalam perkara tindak pidana narkotika (Studi putusan Nomor: 9/Pid.Sus-Anak/2022/PN.Tar). Jurnal Akta Yudisia, 10(1), 73–86.

Fathurrahman, F., Irawan, A., & Fridayanti, S. (2023). Effectiveness of Regional Regulation Number 20 of 2001 regarding regulation of street traders and seasonal street traders in Tarakan City. International Journal of Educational Research & Social Sciences, 429–434.

Irawan, A., & Gusfira, N. (2025). Penanggulangan kejahatan perkarantinan pertanian dan hewan di wilayah perbatasan Indonesia dan Malaysia, Kalimantan Utara. Mubeza: Pemikiran Hukum dan Ekonomi Islam, 16(2), 54–65.

Haeruddin, H., Irawan, A., & Mumaddadah. (2025). Analisis yuridis perlindungan hukum terhadap anak sebagai korban tindak pidana pornografi (Studi kasus Putusan 433/Pid.Sus/2020/PN Dum). Journal of Borneo Border Area, 1(1), 1–15.

Hudariah, R., Irawan, A., & Putra, A. A. (2026). Tinjauan yuridis terhadap penyalahgunaan data pribadi dalam transaksi kartu kredit. Borneo Law Review, 10(1), 52–69.

Irawan, A. (2011). Resosialisasi narapidana anak berkaitan dengan efektivitas pola pembinaan narapidana di Lembaga Pemasyarakatan Anak [Tesis magister, Universitas Andalas].

Irawan, A. (2017). Perlindungan saksi whistleblower dan justice collaborator dalam perspektif kebijakan hukum pidana pemberantasan tindak pidana korupsi di Indonesia. Al-Hurriyah: Jurnal Hukum Islam, 2(1), 69–84.

Irawan, A. (2018). The perspective of criminal law policy on witness protection in corruption eradication case. In International Conference of ASEAN Perspective and Policy (ICAP) (Vol. 1, No. 1, pp. 93–100).

Irawan, A. (2018). Urgensi perlindungan saksi dalam perspektif kebijakan hukum pidana pemberantasan tindak pidana korupsi di Indonesia [Disertasi doktoral, Universitas Andalas].

Irawan, A. (2019). Hukum Islam dalam kerangka pembaruan hukum pidana di Indonesia, dilihat dari perspektif teori hukum pembangunan Mochtar Kusumaatmadja. Al-Hurriyah: Jurnal Hukum Islam, 4(2), 98–110.

Irawan, A. (2019). Hukum tindak pidana korupsi: Aspek yuridis perlindungan saksi dalam pemberantasan tindak pidana korupsi. Kanaka Media Group.

Irawan, A. (2020). Kebijakan hukum pidana dalam pemberantasan tindak pidana korupsi dari perspektif perlindungan terhadap saksi pelapor dan saksi pelaku. Jurnal Hukum Das Sollen, 4(1).

Irawan, A. (2020). Politik hukum pembentukan Undang-Undang Perlindungan Saksi dan Korban, dilihat dari perlindungan whistleblower (saksi pelapor) dan saksi ahli di Indonesia. Jurnal Akta Yudisia, 2(2), 62–75.

Irawan, A. (2021). The dispute resolution of violation of Indonesian forest area based on the decision of the Supreme Court Number 269 K/TUN/2018. Journal of Social Science, 2(2), 117–125.

Irawan, A. (2026). Hukum pidana Indonesia. Nafal Publishing.

Irawan, A. (2026). The U.S. system for handling corruption cases: A criminal law and white-collar crime perspective. Deepublish.

Irawan, A., & Asneliwarni. (2024). Pengantar hukum di Indonesia: Asas dan teori hukum. PT Nafal Global Nusantara.

Irawan, A., & Azhari, A. A. (2023). Memetakan penanggulangan kejahatan perkarantinan pertanian dan hewan di wilayah perbatasan Indonesia dan Malaysia. In Prosiding Seminar Nasional Hukum dan Pembangunan yang Berkelanjutan (No. 3, pp. 170–188). LPPM Universitas Borneo Tarakan.

Irawan, A., & Hamka, M. (2026). Finality of Constitutional Court judicial decisions and the validity of the elected president's office in Indonesia [Finalitas putusan peradilan Mahkamah Konstitusi dan keabsahan jabatan presiden terpilih di Indonesia]. Judex Journal of Judicial Studies, 1(1), 198–223.

Irawan, A., Asneliwarni, A., & Ransangan, J. (2026). Synergizing Dayak Kenyah local wisdom with state law for village fund corruption prevention. Sasi, 32(4), 368–388.

Irawan, A., Astuti, S. A., & Khairi, M. (2021). Model pencegahan berbasis masyarakat terhadap tindak pidana illegal logging di wilayah perbatasan Kalimantan Utara. Pakuan Justice Journal of Law (PAJOUL), 1(2), 1–17.

Irawan, A., Bawaeda, A. F., & Riani, R. S. (2026). When customary court decisions meet state certificates: Ulayat land tenure in East Kalimantan. Societas Law Review, 1(1), 24–47.

Asneliwarni., Irawan, A., & Delmiati, S. (2026). Perampasan aset dalam pembaruan hukum pidana korupsi pada era pemerintahan Prabowo. Unes Journal of Swara Justisia, 10(2), 412–424.

Irawan, A., Ishaq, F. M., & Ishaq, I. (2026). Punished twice: Ne bis in idem between Dayak Kenyah customary sanctions and state penal liability. Greenation International Journal of Law and Social Sciences, 4(4), 1839–1859.

Irawan, A., Nurvianti, D., Fenitra, R. M., & Bosha Ahmed, M. A. I. (2023). The role of institutionalization police support in emergency situation: Evidence from Indonesia. Journal of Human Rights, Culture and Legal System, 3(1), 109–133.

Irawan, A., Ransangan, J., Sentani, R. G., [penulis lain: lengkapi]. (2025). Criminal penalties for foreigners engaged in illegal fishing Indonesia's ZEE impact SDGs. Journal of Sustainable Development and Regulatory Issues, 3(1), 95–120.

Irawan, A., Suryani, N., Asneliwarni, A., [penulis lain: lengkapi]. (2025). Women as victims of human trafficking (TPPO) in North Kalimantan Indonesia from criminal law and Islamic law perspectives. Nagari Law Review, 8(3), 514–530.

Irawan, A., Wahyuni, F., Hanifa, R., Suryani, R. W., [penulis lain: lengkapi]. (2022). The perceptions and tendencies of judges religious court in using the Kitab Kuning (books of fiqh) in Indonesia. Tribakti: Jurnal Pemikiran Keislaman, 33(2), 209–222.

Irawan, A., Wahyuni, F., [penulis lain: lengkapi]. (2025). Transformasi regulasi dan kebijakan hukum pidana dalam ekosistem bisnis digital di Indonesia. Indragiri Law Review, 3(2), 19–28.

Irawan, A., Zein, Y. A., Prakoso, L. Y., Pramono, B., & Rahman, A. (2022). Legal restoration toward children victims of sexual violence at the border of North Kalimantan, Indonesia. Resmilitaris, 12(2), 3367–3382. https://resmilitaris.net/menu-script/index.php/resmilitaris/article/view/451

Jubaidah, Irawan, A., & Putra, A. A. (2023). Perlindungan hukum terhadap pelajar sebagai korban tindak pidana perkosaan. In Prosiding Seminar Nasional Hukum dan Pembangunan yang Berkelanjutan (No. 1, pp. 333–348). LPPM Universitas Borneo Tarakan.

Khairi, M., Irawan, A., & Astuti, S. A. (2021). Perlindungan hak-hak buruh yang mendapatkan pemutusan hubungan kerja (PHK) oleh perusahaan pada masa pandemi Covid-19. Pakuan Justice Journal of Law (PAJOUL), 2(2), 1–17.

Nurvianti, D., Irawan, A., Fridayanti, S., [penulis lain: lengkapi]. (2023). Rethinking the sovereignty principle: Is it a legal provision or a political domain nowadays? Indonesia Law Reform Journal, 3(1), 79–95.

Patton, A., Salim, G., Prakoso, L. Y., Prihantoro, K., Pramono, B., Indarjo, A., DS, S. H., Ransangan, J., Irawan, A., Saleh, R., [penulis lain: lengkapi]. (2021). Strategi pertahanan melalui optimalisasi kesejahteraan masyarakat pesisir perbatasan. Syiah Kuala University Press.

Robert, K., & Irawan, A. (2019). Hukum perlindungan saksi: Dalam pemberantasan tindak pidana korupsi. Thafa Media.

Salim, G., Hendrikus, Indarjo, A., Prakoso, L. Y., Haryono, M. G., Irawan, A., & Ransangan, J. (2022). Characteristics of model growth and mortality of white shrimp (Penaeus merguiensis de Man 1888) in the estuaria of Bengara, Regency Bulungan. IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, 1083(1), Article 012083.

Salinding, M. B., & Irawan, A. (2024). Legal protection of traditional knowledge of indigenous peoples in obtaining economic benefits, human rights perspective. Mahadi: Indonesia Journal of Law, 3(2), 122–128.

Suwandi, Irawan, A., & Fernando, Y. F. (2025). Tinjauan yuridis pencabutan keterangan berita acara pemeriksaan di muka persidangan dalam hukum acara pidana. Journal of Borneo Border Area, 1(1), 89–108.

Swardhyana, G. M. P., & Irawan, A. (2022). Evidence in sexual violence crime cases. International Journal of Educational Research & Social Sciences, 3(5), 1943–1950.

Wahyuni, F., & Irawan, A. (2021a). Criminal sanctions for corruption crimes based on perspective study of renewal law and the relationship with Islamic criminal law. Al-Risalah, 21(2), 219–233.

Wahyuni, F., & Irawan, A. (2021b). Kajian hukum terhadap perangkat desa yang ikut serta dalam kampanye pemilu di Kabupaten Indragiri Hilir. Selodang Mayang: Jurnal Ilmiah Badan Perencanaan Pembangunan Daerah Kabupaten Indragiri Hilir, 7(3), 137–145.

Wahyuni, F., Ayu, R. K., & Irawan, A. (2025). Peningkatan kesadaran hukum bagi anak dari korban kejahatan seksual melalui program pembelajaran tahfidz Al-Qur'an di Kabupaten Indragiri Hilir. Selodang Mayang: Jurnal Ilmiah Badan Perencanaan Pembangunan Daerah Kabupaten Indragiri Hilir, 11(2), 114–127.

Wahyuni, F., Irawan, A., & Ayu, R. K. (2024). Punishment for individuals committing sexual crimes against children: A comparative analysis of positive and traditional criminal law in Indonesia. Kanun Jurnal Ilmu Hukum, 26(1), 216–231. https://jurnal.usk.ac.id/kanun/article/view/20906

Wahyuni, F., Irawan, A., & Rahmah, S. (2021a). Criminal liability for performers of the persecution of religious figures in Indonesia [Pertanggungjawaban pidana bagi pelaku penganiayaan terhadap tokoh agama di Indonesia]. Jurnal Cendekia Hukum, 7(1), 107–120. https://e-jurnal.stih-pm.ac.id/index.php/cendekeahukum/article/view/358

Wahyuni, F., Irawan, A., & Rahmah, S. (2021b). The legal protection for children of sexual violence victims in Indragiri Hilir Regency. International Journal of Educational Research & Social Sciences, 2(2), 322–327.

Yossy, T. M., Irawan, A., & Mumaddadah. (2023). Pemusnahan barang bukti yang telah diputus oleh hakim pada Kejaksaan Negeri Tarakan. In Prosiding Seminar Nasional Hukum dan Pembangunan yang Berkelanjutan (Vol. 3, pp. 319–332). LPPM Universitas Borneo Tarakan.

Authors

Dian Wijaya
dianpranatawijaya09@gmail.com (Primary Contact)
Rahmad Bakhri
Wijaya, D., & Bakhri, R. (2026). The Paradigm Shift in Indonesian Contract Law: A Case Study of Oral Employment Agreements Amid the Demand for Written Legal Certainty. Societas Law Review, 1(1), 160–191. Retrieved from https://journal.aisholarborneo.org/index.php/solrev/article/view/31

Article Details

Similar Articles

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.